Fact or Fiction: Airships Docked with the Top of The Empire State Building

The dramatic black-and-white photo of a giant airship docked at the Empire State Building’s spire looks like something straight out of Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow. At first glance, it might seem like a moment of history captured on film—but it’s not. The photo is actually a composite image, combining the USS Los Angeles, a US Navy rigid airship, with the iconic New York skyscraper. Adding to the confusion, real photos exist of airships connecting to high mast towers, showing passengers disembarking from the nose. These, however, depict British High Masts used for the R100 and R101 airships and have no connection to New York. The concept of using the Empire State Building as an airship dock was proposed in the early 20th century but quickly proved unfeasible. Let’s delve into the origins of this ambitious idea, why it failed, and how it lingers in imagination today.
The Origin of the Empire State Building Airship Dock Idea
In 1929, Alfred E. Smith, former New York governor and leader of the Empire State Building’s development, announced plans to extend the skyscraper’s height by 200 feet. This decision made the building the tallest in the world, surpassing the Chrysler Building. To justify the added height, Smith pitched the spire as a mooring mast for airships.
The concept was bold: airships like the Graf Zeppelin would dock at the spire, allowing passengers to step off and be on the streets of New York within minutes. The idea captured public imagination, but airship experts and engineers were less enthusiastic. Even Dr. Hugo Eckener, commander of the Graf Zeppelin, said the plan was impractical due to safety and logistical challenges.
Why the Airship Dock Never Worked
While the idea of an Empire State Building airship dock sounded futuristic, it was doomed by several major flaws:
Dangerous Wind Conditions
At 1,250 feet, the spire is constantly battered by high winds. Early tests proved how difficult it was for airships to hover near the tower. In 1931, a private blimp managed to briefly connect to the spire for a mere 3 minutes before being driven off by 40-mile-per-hour winds.
No Ground Crew Support
Airship docking typically requires dozens of crew members to secure ropes and stabilize the craft. This level of support was impossible on a skyscraper’s narrow spire.
Passenger Access Issues
The docking area above the 102nd floor was cramped and dangerous. Passengers would have had to step onto a circular terrace just two and a half feet wide with a low parapet. The thought of disembarking from a moving airship onto such a precarious platform was more terrifying than convenient.
Minimal Demand for Airship Travel
At the time, passenger airship travel was still a niche market. Even the Germans, who led the airship industry, had not requested a dock in New York.
The End of the Empire State Building Airship Dock
The Empire State Building opened in May 1931, but the airship docking equipment was never built. A few tests were attempted to generate publicity, including the aforementioned three-minute connection by a dirigible in September 1931. However, these efforts only proved the idea was impractical and unsafe.
By the mid-1930s, the spire’s purpose shifted to broadcasting. In 1936, the German airship Hindenburg flew over the building en route to Lakehurst, New Jersey, but didn’t attempt to dock. The tragic crash of the Hindenburg in 1937 marked the end of commercial airship travel, making the dock’s concept obsolete.
Legacy of the Empire State Building Airship Dock
Despite its failure, the idea of the Empire State Building as an airship dock remains a captivating part of its history. The iconic spire, designed as a mooring mast, now serves as a broadcasting tower. The myth of airships docking there endures, fueled by doctored photos and public fascination with the golden age of airships.
While the dream of passengers strolling from an airship onto a New York City skyscraper never became reality, the story highlights the bold vision of early 20th-century architects and engineers. Today, the spire stands as a testament to human ambition—even when that ambition soars a little too high.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Did any airship actually dock at the Empire State Building?
No airship ever truly docked there successfully. A few tests were attempted, but high winds and safety concerns made docking impossible. - Why was the spire originally designed as an airship dock?
The airship dock concept was a marketing strategy to justify extending the building’s height, ensuring it would be the tallest skyscraper in the world. - What is the spire used for now?
The spire was repurposed as a broadcasting tower and remains a vital part of New York City’s communication infrastructure.
Responses